Note; when watching videos of Kyle today, bear in mind these days he's turning waaaay more RPM than with his Pantera in this old video, major point being, if you crank a P6 up to 2200RPMs instead of 2000, then it'll react more quickly, also. Minor point of this video being, even if you dream of 3D, if you're a beginner learning the ropes, a P6 absolutely won't hold you back whilst being great at suffering the knocks and abuse of a new pilot just because it's a plastic fantastic! So yes, it's actually valid to compare a Kraken/RAW 580 vs P6 . . . sort of.
Nuance
Why only sort of? Same reason Motor Trend magazine pits Camaro, Challenger, and Mustang in a shootout but including a Tahoe in the mix would be stupid. Yes, they all have 4-wheels, V-8 engines, and heated leather seats, but we're talking sporty coupes vs an SUV - different design language!
Same with Kraken 580 Nitro vs Pantera P6 models. They may use the same OS MAX 55HZ-R engine and 600mm blades, but the truth is the Kraken/RAW 580 Nitro family actually more closely compares to the Tron 5.5N, T-REX 600XN, or Fury 57 SN. And it's for the same reason . . . these four share the same design language whilst a P6 is a totally different animal. Smack a P6 into the ground and odds are damage doesn't amount to a car payment, as one example.
So the comparison is more like apples and oranges! Let's see why.
- Kraken 580 Nitro (580-600mm)
- RAW 580 Nitro (580-600mm)
- Tron 5.5N (580-610mm)
- T-REX 600XN (580-600mm)
- Fury 57 SN (580-600mm)
- Pantera P6 (580-620mm)
Design language
Sharing a design language means Kraken/RAW 580Nitro, Tron 5.5N, T-REX 600N, and Fury 57 SN are all built up from flat pieces of carbon fiber sheet material plus blocks to hold bearings and gears in alignment. And more bits and bobs to hold the servos to the side frames, a separate cooling fan shroud, etc. Lots of pieces.
However, when I say a P6 is an altogether different animal because of the monocoque molded frame, which snap together like Legos - complete with servo mounts and integral fan shroud - all molded of impact resistant engineering polymer (plastic, like what's used in Glock handguns). These are totally different technologies!
So while they all turn 600mm blades, they don't share the same design language. And this is true in exactly the same way both Colt 1911 M1 and Glock 21 automatic pistols send 230 grains downrange at 830ft/s but differ because the frame of one is made of steel versus plastic for the other. And neither is always better, or always worse, because they're designed for different missions!
Apples and oranges
So your pal's an idiot because a Kraken or Nitron are neither better nor worse than a P6 for the same reason an apple is neither better, nor worse, than an orange. Sure, they're similar in being a tasty fruit tucked in with a sandwich in your lunchbox, but they're totally different beyond taste - citrus is more work because it must first be peeled and sectioned versus a quick polish on your shirt before taking a bite of the apple!
Real question is; what benefit do I get from Kraken 580 Nitro versus Pantera P6 or, what's in it for me?
An example where a P6 may be better for you is it's physically bigger than the Kraken 580. Bigger than the T-REX 600N, and Tron 5.5N, also. In fact, size-wise, a P6 is more like a 700. And, critically, this also makes the P6 a lot easier to see in flight.